Wednesday, September 09, 2009

Jones fracture

I came across this little gem from 1902:

"SOME months ago, whilst dancing, I trod on the outer sideof my foot, my heel at the moment being off the ground. Some-thing gave way midway down my foot, and I at once suspected arupture of the peroneus longus tendon. By the help of a friend I managed to walk to my cab, a distance of over 300 or 400 yards.The following morning I carefully examined my foot and dis-covered that my tendon was intact. There was a slight swelling over the base of the fifth metatarsal bone. I endeavored to obtainc repitus and failed. A finger on the spot gave exquisite pain. Body pressure on the toes, even the slightest, was painful; butwhen the pressure was deviated to the outer side the pain wasstill greater. Extension of the ankle and flexion of the toes wereimmediately felt at the base of the fifth metatarsal."

This was Sir Robert Jones talking about his fracture that became known as a Jones fracture.

Back to home

Saturday, August 15, 2009

Barefoot Running

I am not opposed to the barefoot running movement. It just some of the promoters of barefoot running that I have a problem with. They are like religious zealots that are fanatical about the whole concept of barefoot running. They use nonsensical non-scientific mumbo jumbo to support what they do. They twist research to make it sound like it supports their cause. They dismiss research that is anti-barefoot. They take any research that is anti-running shoe as evidence that proves running barefoot is better (huh?).

At the end of the day, there is no evidence that running barefoot is even ideal, let alone beneficial. There is also no evidence that its not. I blogged about this here and see Podiatry Arena: Barefoot Running for a balanced discussion on the pros and cons of barefoot running. For a bit a fun check out the zealotry on some of the running forums when it comes to discussing this. Trying to be rational with these people is like trying to argue a religion - not going to win that one.

I have no doubt that the research will show that there will be some benefits to running barefoot; I have no doubt it will also show that there will also have some risks. What we need is better evidence of who and when it should be used. I have no doubt that barefoot running should be a part of a balanced running program for all those who can tolerate it, but it should be used in moderation.

Back to home

Saturday, August 08, 2009

MASS Foot Position Theory for Foot Orthotics

MASS foot orthotic position theory has been proposed by Ed Glaser, DPM from Sole Supports Inc. MASS stands for Maximum Arch Subtalar Supination. It is a position of the foot that is much more supinated than the traditional subtalar joint neutral position, but also maintains the forefoot on the ground (no varus or valgus captured). Ed advocates the use of semi-weightbearing foam box as opposed to plaster (though it is not difficult to reproduce the position non-weightbearing with plaster bandage). The position results in a very different foot orthotic shape that is what is traditionally used. For more see comments on the Boot Camp site: MASS Foot Position Theory and the threads on Podiatry Arena tagged with MASS position theory (they do get a little heated).

Back to home page

Saturday, July 25, 2009

Laser treatment for toenail fungus

This is an interesting one to blog about, but has everything to do with innovation and bringing products to the market. The laser treatment for toenail fungus (onychomycosis) is a recent innovation. The clinical trials by the company, PinPointe, are underway and no results are yet available. However, many clinics are beginning to widely use and tout this treatment. All the evidence for it is the testimonials and unsubstantiated claims. There are many clips on You Tube about it. Its not cheap and costs a lot of money. My interest in this was piqued when this marketing of a product before the evidence comes in as to its efficacy is lacking. This is a pattern that has been repeated many times in the history of the profession. More often than not, the use of the product dies off as the evidence come in. Don’t we ever learn by our mistakes?

(See this on Podiatry Arena: Nail fungus laser treatment; Laser treatment for nail fungus)

Back to home page

The MOSI Foot Orthotics

If the foot is abnormally pronating and causing problems, there is only one way it can be stopped. It has to be stopped by the use of a force on the medial side of the assumed subtalar joint axis. While this makes intuitive sense, the problem arises as the position of the axis varies substantially. There are clinical tests that can tell us where the axis is, so we can work out where the force from a foot orthoses has to be applied.

When the axis is located more medially located, the problem comes that there is very little room on the plantar surface medial to the joint axis for that force to be applied. To apply the force various orthotic design parameters have been developed. There is the DC Wedge, Kirby medial skive, the the Blake Inverted foot orthotic.

Recently a unique design, the MOSI foot orthotic has been proposed by Paul Harradine, and Simon Collins., Chris Webb , Lawrence Bevan. The MOSI orthotic stands for medial oblique shell inclination. The aim of this design is to incline upwards the shell of the orthotic on the medial side of the subtalar joint axis. It is an interesting innovative design that makes good theoretical sense.

Back to home page

Tuesday, June 09, 2009

a.k.a. Parish and Bell

Just an update on the previous post on Parish and Bell and all the dissatisfied "patients" that were left in no-mans-land with the bankruptcy and no one was held accountable for the duty-of-care.

Back to home page

Wednesday, June 03, 2009

Bad research

In the most recent issue of the Journal of the American Podiatric Medical Association is this paper: Robert Fridman, Jarrett D. Cain, and Lowell Weil, Jr: Extracorporeal Shockwave Therapy for Interdigital Neuroma: A Randomized, Placebo-Controlled, Double-Blind Trial. J Am Podiatr Med Assoc 2009 99: 191-193. This was a randomised controlled trial comparing shockwave therapy for mortons neuroma to a placebo.

The purpose of a RCT is to determine how much more effective an intervention is compared to a placebo. To do this the correct way to analyze a RCT is to compare the outcomes BETWEEN the intervention and placebo groups (I could cite some references here, but every book on clinical trials says that, so take your pick).

The authors in this study did a WITHIN groups analysis which is the wrong way! They found a statistically significant difference between baseline and outcome in the shockwave group and no difference in the placebo group. Doing a WITHIN groups comparison, you have no way of knowing how much of the change in the shockwave group was due to the placebo effect which is why you do a BETWEEN groups comparison. On the basis of the analysis that the authors did, they concluded that: “Extracorporeal shockwave therapy is a possible alternative to surgical excision for Morton’s neuroma” and made recommendations for its use.

In the paper the authors tabulated the individual results for each participant. I put those numbers into a stats program and did a BETWEEN groups comparison and got a p value for the difference of 0.27 – not even close to being statistically significantly different! The authors actually showed that shockwave therapy for neuromas was no better than a placebo! – the opposite of what they claimed!

Not to mention that this research was also very underpowered and there were dropouts in the placebo group that should have been included in the analysis (look up ‘intention to treat’).

I seriously question how this publication made it past the journal’s review process. Comments here: Shockwave therapy for Morton's neuroma.

Back to home page