Sunday, March 01, 2009
Parish & Bell
Parish and Bell are a foot orthotic clinic in the UK that advertise nationally, apparently use high pressure sales and marketing techniques as well as charge what appear to be extortionist prices for foot orthotics. They recently went bust leaving a lot of disgruntled patients and numerous threads on a number of forums. The one on Podiatry Arena is most interesting as Les Bailey from Parish and Bell tried to rationalise what happen by blaming everyone else for their demise and claiming that the criticism were just Podiatrists being jealous. See the Parish and Bell thread and see the reactions from Podiatrists and patients -- judge for yourself.
Back to home page
Back to home page
Labels:
parish and bell
Sunday, December 21, 2008
That time of the year
What to blog about today (especially when not feeling well)?
Maybe go and have a read of this:
Best Podiatry Arena Quotes for 2008 (it really sums up just how gullible and blind with blinkers some people can be!)
All the best to all for the holiday season.
Back to home page
Maybe go and have a read of this:
Best Podiatry Arena Quotes for 2008 (it really sums up just how gullible and blind with blinkers some people can be!)
All the best to all for the holiday season.
Back to home page
Sunday, November 30, 2008
Critical Thinking
Within the discipline of Critical Thinking, all the strategies that can be used to make arguments are well researched and documented. The fallacies of logic are clear. One of the false types of arguments is know as the straw man argument in which you define your opponents position as something that its not and then argue against that position. Wikipedia defines it as:
A straw man argument is an informal fallacy based on misrepresentation of an opponent's position. To "set up a straw man," one describes a position that superficially resembles an opponent's actual view, yet is easier to refute. Then, one attributes that position to the opponent. For example, someone might deliberately overstate the opponent's position. While a straw man argument may work as a rhetorical technique—and succeed in persuading people—it carries little or no real evidential weight, since the opponent's actual argument has not been refuted.
Here a some Podiatry Arena threads:
Challenging MASS
Challenging SALRE
Claims of Foot Orthoses Superiority
Have a read of them. Guess what? Spot the straw man arguments!
All this sums up the point that Steve the Footman made about Podiatry Arena: "What other profession has a forum that gives its members access to its most significant researchers and clinicians? You can ask any question you want and get informed and experienced replys that include links to multiple research papers. New research is discussed and critically appraised immediately. It is like having a blowtorch applied to the cherished beliefs of the profession. It is like having an academic review panel of 8000 people at your fingertips.And I think it is the major development in sports podiatry in 2008."
Back to home page
A straw man argument is an informal fallacy based on misrepresentation of an opponent's position. To "set up a straw man," one describes a position that superficially resembles an opponent's actual view, yet is easier to refute. Then, one attributes that position to the opponent. For example, someone might deliberately overstate the opponent's position. While a straw man argument may work as a rhetorical technique—and succeed in persuading people—it carries little or no real evidential weight, since the opponent's actual argument has not been refuted.
Here a some Podiatry Arena threads:
Challenging MASS
Challenging SALRE
Claims of Foot Orthoses Superiority
Have a read of them. Guess what? Spot the straw man arguments!
All this sums up the point that Steve the Footman made about Podiatry Arena: "What other profession has a forum that gives its members access to its most significant researchers and clinicians? You can ask any question you want and get informed and experienced replys that include links to multiple research papers. New research is discussed and critically appraised immediately. It is like having a blowtorch applied to the cherished beliefs of the profession. It is like having an academic review panel of 8000 people at your fingertips.And I think it is the major development in sports podiatry in 2008."
Back to home page
Thursday, November 06, 2008
The abductory twist
During gait, in a number of patients, just as the heel comes off the ground, the foot often abducts. There is no doubt this happens and its called an abductory twist.
What is interesting about it, is that two different biologically plausible and theoretically coherent theories can be used to explain it:
1. Foot pronates beyond midstance--> internal rotation moment to leg; the opposite leg is swinging forward and rotating the pelvis --> externally rotation moment to leg on ground --> conflict between proximal external rotation and distal internal rotation moments -- initially the pronated foot causing the internal rotation moment wins the battle and foot does not resupinate to accommodate that proximal external rotation moment ..... eventually as heel comes off ground, friction between the ground and foot can no longer no longer resist the external rotation moment coming from above --> abductory twist
2. As heel starts to come off the ground a functional hallux limitus kicks in (for whatever reason); as the body has to move forward over the first MPJ, it can do so by a number of mechanisms; one of these is to abduct the foot to roll off the medial side of the blocked first MPJ --> abductory twist
This is a classic example of how a fact (the presence of an abductory twist during gait) can be explained by two competing theories (this is what make clinical biomechanics fun).
Lets wee what others think on the abductory twist.
Back to home page For more: http://www.fridayfitnessguru.com/i-just-learned-about-the-medial-heel-whip/ http://www.whatispodiatry.com/questions/what-is-an-abductory-twist/
What is interesting about it, is that two different biologically plausible and theoretically coherent theories can be used to explain it:
1. Foot pronates beyond midstance--> internal rotation moment to leg; the opposite leg is swinging forward and rotating the pelvis --> externally rotation moment to leg on ground --> conflict between proximal external rotation and distal internal rotation moments -- initially the pronated foot causing the internal rotation moment wins the battle and foot does not resupinate to accommodate that proximal external rotation moment ..... eventually as heel comes off ground, friction between the ground and foot can no longer no longer resist the external rotation moment coming from above --> abductory twist
2. As heel starts to come off the ground a functional hallux limitus kicks in (for whatever reason); as the body has to move forward over the first MPJ, it can do so by a number of mechanisms; one of these is to abduct the foot to roll off the medial side of the blocked first MPJ --> abductory twist
This is a classic example of how a fact (the presence of an abductory twist during gait) can be explained by two competing theories (this is what make clinical biomechanics fun).
Lets wee what others think on the abductory twist.
Back to home page For more: http://www.fridayfitnessguru.com/i-just-learned-about-the-medial-heel-whip/ http://www.whatispodiatry.com/questions/what-is-an-abductory-twist/
Labels:
biomechanics
Tuesday, October 21, 2008
Recomended Running Shoes
Advising runners what shoe to use is always difficult. Shoes change frequently and what suits one runners does not necessarily suit another, even if they appear to have similar needs. Keeping on top of who needs what and what company makes what is always difficult. This grid is a good step in the right direction to pick up what shoes models fit into what category of running shoe.
Back to home page
Back to home page
Labels:
running shoes
Monday, September 22, 2008
Gout
I use this quote (not sure where I got it from) during lectures to students to suggest just how painful gout is: “Screw up the vise as tightly as possible - you have rheumatism; give it another turn, and it is gout” - Anonymous
Here are a couple of good threads at Podiatry Arena on Gout:
The latest on gout (this one has all the very latest news)
Reason for gout in more peripheral joints (this one looks at reasons why the first MPJ is the most common site for gout.
For this interested in magical cures; or what people with gout are reading; or want some good dietary advice, there are these eBooks:
The Ultimate Instant Gout Relief Report
Labels:
gout
Monday, September 08, 2008
Running Shoe Forum
I have been asked to do some work on a Running Shoe forum. Here are some links to the section that need some work: Running shoes Nike Brooks Best running shoes New balance Adidas Asics Mizuno Spira Saucony Newton Kids Running Shoe Reviews . The forum has not been officially launched yet, but they are looking for people to help out to get the content developed before the official launch.
Back to home page
Back to home page
Labels:
running shoes
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)